Apache Kafka and A Comparison with RabbitMQ

Kafka Introduction

Apache Kafka is heavily used in my work now. Therefore, I thought it would be useful and helpful to write a post about it.

Kafka is an event streaming platform. Apache Kafka defines event streaming as the following:

Technically speaking, event streaming is the practice of capturing data in real-time from event sources like databases, sensors, mobile devices, cloud services, and software applications in the form of streams of events; storing these event streams durably for later retrieval; manipulating, processing, and reacting to the event streams in real-time as well as retrospectively; and routing the event streams to different destination technologies as needed. Event streaming thus ensures a continuous flow and interpretation of data so that the right information is at the right place, at the right time.

Installation and Hello World with Kafka

For how to install and run Kafka on other systems, please refer to the official documentation: https://kafka.apache.org/quickstart

I am using Mac. Homebrew is a very nice tool to install and manage packages on Mac, quite similar to apt-get on Ubuntu. The App store on macOS is enough to install, upgrade, and update applications for normal users, but definitely not sufficient for developers. Honestly, I think Apple should acquire Homebrew and integrate it into macOS.

Install Java

brew install java
java --version

Install Kafka

brew install kafka

Start Zookeeper

Open a new terminal, run the command to start ZooKeeper, because Kafka leverages ZooKeeper to manage clusters.

zookeeper-server-start /usr/local/etc/kafka/zookeeper.properties

Start Kafka

Note: Edit /usr/local/etc/kafka/server.properties to change listeners to listeners=PLAINTEXT://localhost:9092

Open a new terminal, run the command to start Kafka:

kafka-server-start /usr/local/etc/kafka/server.properties

Create Kafka Topic

Create a test topic with replication-factor=1(no extra replicas) and partition=1(only 1 partition)

kafka-topics --create --bootstrap-server localhost:9092 --replication-factor 1 --partitions 1 --topic test

Initialize 2 Kafka Producers

Open 2 other terminals and run the command to start Kafka producers:

kafka-console-producer --broker-list localhost:9092 --topic test

Write 4 messages in the following sequence:

1. producer1 –> message 1
2. producer2 –> message 1
3. producer1 –> message 2
4. producer2 –> message 2

(base) xxxx@MacBook-Air-2 ~ % kafka-console-producer –broker-list localhost:9092 –topic test producer1 message 1
producer1 message 2

(base) xxxx@MacBook-Air-2 ~ % kafka-console-producer –broker-list localhost:9092 –topic test producer2 message1
producer2 message2

Start a Kafka Consumer

Open a terminal and run the command to initialize a kafka consumer:

kafka-console-consumer --bootstrap-server localhost:9092 --topic test --from-beginning

And we will the 4 messages written before:

(base) xxxx@MacBook-Air-2 ~ % kafka-console-consumer –bootstrap-server localhost:9092 –topic test –from-beginning
producer1 message 1
producer2 message1
producer1 message 2
producer2 message2

Kafka is using Pub-Sub pattern. We can create multiple producers and consumers for a certain topic to play with it.

A Comparison between Kafka and RabbitMQ

By design Kafka is an event streaming platform while RabbitMQ is a message queue.

Here are some of their major differences between Apache Kafka and RabbitMQ:

Generally, Kafka retains messages while RabbitMQ doesn’t; RabbitMQ offers more complex and flexible ways of routing messages and prioritizing messages, while Kafka supports a simple Pub-Sub pattern.

Regarding performance, both systems can be scaled to process millions of messages per second. Some benchmarking results suggest that:

1. Given same resource configuration, Kafka has higher throughput than RabbitMQ;
2. RabbitMQ delivers lower message latency than Kafka

Conclusion

Both Apache Kafka and RabbitMQ are great systems. When complex routing and prioritizing of messages are required, RabbitMQ is the preferred option; when message ordering and retention are needed, Kafka is the choice.
In terms business cases, RabbitMQ is more used for transactional systems and is perfect for routing message between clusters of microservices whereas Kafka is more used in analytical systems such as data streaming and pipelines.